AV-Test releases first Windows 8 test stats

Posted by   Virus Bulletin on   Apr 5, 2013

Corporate and consumer products rated against Windows Defender baseline.

Independent testing house AV-Test.org has released its first set of figures for solutions run on Windows 8, covering 26 consumer and nine corporate products. At the consumer level, Microsoft's Windows Defender, included as standard in Windows 8, is treated as a baseline measure which others are expected to surpass, but a couple of stragglers manage to perform less well than this minimal target. In the corporate selection, Microsoft System Center Endpoint Protection took the same role, and again not all third-party offerings were able to outperform Microsoft.

Products are rated on a range of criteria including speed, system resource use, and false positives as well as protection against a range of threats in realistic scenarios. Each of three areas is given a rating out of six for a potential total of 18 points, with 10 being considered the minimum to achieve certification. In previous tests points have also been awarded for repair and cleanup, but this part of the test has been moved out to a separate report, which is expected out later in the year.

The top performer in the consumer tests was Bitdefender, with 17 points, dropping the single point on speed measures. Close behind was BullGuard, using Bitdefender's detection engine, with 16.5. Kaspersky Lab also did very well with a score of 16. Other quality performers included AVG, G Data, Symantec's Norton, Tencent, Trend Micro and Webroot, all on 15.5, and Avast's free edition and China's Qihoo 360 both on 15. Close behind were ESET, F-Secure and Panda on 14.5, and Check Point's Zone Alarm on 14. Not so impressive were Lavasoft's AdAware and GFI VIPRE on 13, and products from Avira, McAfee and PC Tools on 12.5. Only just respectable on 12 was MicroWorld's eScan, with the baseline set by Microsoft's Defender at 11.5. Named and shamed as being worse than the free product built into Windows 8 were offerings from AhnLab and Comodo, both on 10 points and only just making the grade for basic certification.

In the corporate set, the baseline was set a little higher at 12.5, but was comforatbly beaten by leading performers Fortinet and Symantec, both doing very well with a score of 16.5 points out of a possible 18. Also putting in good showings were Webroot on 15, F-Secure and Sophos on 14.5 and Kaspersky on 14. McAfee's VirusScan Enterprise didn't do too badly at 13.5 points, a full point clear of Microsoft's baseline, but Trend Micro's OfficeScan was found wanting with a lowly 12 points, still enough for certification.

Testing was carried out during January and February; full details can be found at the AV-Test.org website here. VB's own in-house testing covered Windows 8 late last year, with details available here; our next set of results, on Windows XP, are due out in the next few weeks and the deadline for the next comparative, on Windows 8's server sibling Windows Server 2012, has been announced for April 17th.

Posted on 4 April 2013 by John Hawes

twitter.png
fb.png
linkedin.png
googleplus.png
reddit.png

 

Latest posts:

We are more ready for IPv6 email than we may think

Though IPv6 is gradually replacing IPv4 on the Internet's network layer, email is lagging behind, the difficulty in blocking spam sent over IPv6 cited as a reason not to move. But would we really have such a hard time blocking spam sent over IPv6?

Subtle change could see a reduction in installation of malicious Chrome extensions

Google has made a subtle change to its Chrome browser, banning the inline installation of new extensions, thus making it harder for malware authors to trick users into unwittingly installing malicious extensions.

Paper: EternalBlue: a prominent threat actor of 2017–2018

We publish a paper by researchers from Quick Heal Security Labs in India, who study the EternalBlue and DoublePulsar exploits in full detail.

'North Korea' a hot subject among VB2018 talks

Several VB2018 papers deal explicitly or implicitly with threats that have been attributed to North Korean actors.

Expired domain led to SpamCannibal's blacklist eating the whole world

The domain of the little-used SpamCannibal DNS blacklist had expired, resulting in it effectively listing every single IP address.

We have placed cookies on your device in order to improve the functionality of this site, as outlined in our cookies policy. However, you may delete and block all cookies from this site and your use of the site will be unaffected. By continuing to browse this site, you are agreeing to Virus Bulletin's use of data as outlined in our privacy policy.