Magic lanterns shine at terrorists

Posted by   Virus Bulletin on   Dec 19, 2007

Virus Bulletin finds 40% of users think governments should write viruses to bug terrorists.

In a survey of visitors to the Virus Bulletin website, 40% of computer users said they thought it was a good idea for governments to write viruses to bug terrorists - however, security professionals disagree.

It is an idea that surfaces every now and again: since modern malware allows criminals to get a very detailed picture of what's happening on a user's computer, why not switch roles and write 'malware' that gives good people, say a government, insight in what bad people, say terrorists, are doing on their computers?

The latest to come up with such a plan was the German government who, as reported by The Register last month, have started hiring coders to write software that can be used to hack into terrorists' computers.

Righard Zwienenberg, Chief Research Officer at Norman, commented on the subject in Virus Bulletin earlier in the year, describing why he thought such 'magic lanterns' were a bad idea. He still feels strongly: "It's a rather stupid and ignorant idea. The security industry is progressing into advanced proactive detection techniques and trojans like this will most likely be found by security software that is acting on the behaviour."

Of course, a government could force vendors to let their trojans bypass security, but the story does not end there, Zwienenberg continues: "The captured information has to go somewhere or has to be picked up. These communications may be blocked by a firewall or logged. If the trojan installs a backdoor so the police can enter the system, this may open up possibilities for others to do the same. And what if the police system is infected and a piece of malicious code piggy-backs on the communication through the backdoor into the suspect's computer?"

Alex Eckelberry, president of security software company Sunbelt, concurs: "In order for law enforcement to truly make such a trojan undetectable, they would need to get the anti-malware vendors on board, which would create a serious problem of ethics for vendors." Eckelberry feels it would be extremely difficult to get vendors to agree to non-detection, pointing out that it would actually be to an anti-malware vendor's advantage to advertise that they detect magic lanterns, as a PR/marketing push. (Indeed in 2002, VB reported that approximately 100% of the audience in Graham Cluley's VB2002 presentation 'e-bugs: should anti-virus products detect them?' felt they would like AV vendors to include detection of such programs.)

And what, Eckelberry wonders, will happen when magic lanterns start to spread in the wild? "This will certainly occur. For example, a suspected criminal could sell his laptop on eBay, and the magic lantern could then spread."

More of Righard Zwienenberg's thoughts on the subject can be read here.

Posted on 19 December 2007 by Virus Bulletin

twitter.png
fb.png
linkedin.png
googleplus.png
reddit.png

 

Latest posts:

The Virus Bulletin conference returns home: VB2019 to take place in London

In 2019, the Virus Bulletin conference is set to return home, with VB2019 taking place in London, UK.

Guest blog: The case for increasing transparency in cybersecurity

In a guest blog post, Kaspersky Lab's Anton Shingarev considers the case for increasing transparency in cybersecurity.

VB2018 preview: Workshops

Workshops make their VB Conference debut during VB2018, giving delegates the opportunity to learn the basics of kernel-level malware analysis, Android reverse-engineering and artificial intelligence.

New article: Through the looking glass: webcam interception and protection in kernel mode

Today we publish a short article by Ronen Slavin and Michael Maltsev, researchers at Reason Software Company, who dive into the video capturing internals on Windows, and explain how this can be used by a malicious actor to steal images recorded by a…

VB2018 preview: The botnet landscape - live threats and steps for mitigation (Small Talk)

In a Small Talk at VB2018, Spamhaus's Simon Forster will present the organization's research into the botnet landscape and will discuss with the audience topics such as how the rise of anonymzation techniques and the hosting of botnets on…

We have placed cookies on your device in order to improve the functionality of this site, as outlined in our cookies policy. However, you may delete and block all cookies from this site and your use of the site will be unaffected. By continuing to browse this site, you are agreeing to Virus Bulletin's use of data as outlined in our privacy policy.