AV-test.org issues latest figures

Posted by   Virus Bulletin on   Mar 13, 2008

In-depth testing covers multiple factors.

Independent testing body AV-Test.org has released its latest set of results, with a large group of products tested against a number of criteria including proactive detection, spotting and removing active infections, and outbreak response times, as well as simple detection rates.

The results show how companies and their products fare against the latest range of samples arriving at AV-Test, with results of checking new arrivals used to determine the accuracy of heuristics and the efficacy of behavioural detection systems. Updates were also monitored over the test period to determine when companies added detection for new items not spotted using heuristics or generic detection. Detection and effective removal of active malware, including rootkits, is also measured, as is the impact on system performance.

As in AV-Comparatives' recent figures, multi-engine products such as AEC's Trustport, G DATA's AVK and the gateway scanning product WebWasher all performed very strongly in the pure detection test, with Avira's AntiVir also achieving very high scores in both malware and 'potentially unwanted' categories.

The multi-engine products showed their weakness when it came to scanning times and false positives however, and also fared poorly against rootkits, while Avira did well across the board, ranking 'good' or 'very good' in all categories. The only other product to achieve this feat was Sophos, with Symantec and Panda let down only by their response times to outbreaks, marked as merely 'Satisfactory', and McAfee also failing to excel in scanning speed.

The results of the tests are shown in full below.

Overall results


Productmalware on demandadware / spyware on demandfalse positivesscan speedproactive detectionresponse timesrootkit detectioncleaning
AntiVir (Avira)++++ (*1)++++++++
Avast! (Alwil)+++++o+oo
AVG+++ (*1)++oo+o
AVK (G Data)++++o--+++---
BitDefender+++o-++++o
ClamAV--------++----
Dr Weboooo+o++
eScan+oo-+++----
eTrust / VET (CA)----++o---+++
Fortinet-GWoo--++++n/a (*2)n/a (*2)
F-Prot (Frisk)+o++-ooo
F-Secure+o+o++++++
Ikarus++++o+++oo
K7 Computing----o-------
Kaspersky+oo-+++++
McAfee+++++o+o+++
Microsoft+o++o---o++
Nod32 (Eset)+++++++++++
Normanoo+-+ooo
Norton (Symantec)++++++++o++++
Panda++++++o++o
QuickHeal (CAT)--oooo-o
Risingo++oooo+
Sophos+++++++++++
Trend Micro++++++++++
TrustPort++++---++++----
VBA32-ooo+oo+
VirusBuster----+o-oo+
WebWasher-GW++++o++++++n/a (*2)n/a (*2)
ZoneAlarm+oo-++++o

Index
++ = very good> 98%> 98%no FP  < 2 h  
+ = good> 95%> 95%1 FP  2 - 4 h  
o = satisfactory> 90%> 90%2 FP  4 - 6 h  
- = poor> 85%> 85%3 FP  6 - 8 h  
-- = very poor< 85%< 85%> 3 FP  > 8 h  

Notes
(1) the free (personal) edition does not include ad- and spyware detection, so the results would be "--"
(2) not available (this is a gateway product)

Detection rates for malware, adware and spyware


ProductMalware samplesAdware and Spyware
AntiVir (Avira)99.3%99.1%
Avast! (Alwil)98.8%97.9%
AVG96.3%98.6%
AVK (G Data)99.9%99.9%
BitDefender97.8%98.8%
ClamAV84.8%82.4%
Dr Web90.4%92.8%
eScan96.7%92.1%
eTrust / VET (CA)72.1%56.5%
Fortinet-GW92.4%91.2%
F-Prot (Frisk)96.7%92.0%
F-Secure96.8%93.5%
Ikarus98.0%98.8%
K7 Computing65.5%59.5%
Kaspersky97.2%92.0%
McAfee95.6%98.6%
Microsoft97.8%91.5%
Nod32 (Eset)97.8%96.3%
Norman92.8%91.9%
Norton (Symantec)95.7%98.6%
Panda95.6%95.6%
QuickHeal (CAT)85.7%86.7%
Rising94.1%95.9%
Sophos98.1%98.8%
Trend Micro98.7%95.1%
TrustPort99.6%99.8%
VBA3289.9%92.1%
VirusBuster76.2%77.8%
WebWasher-GW99.9%99.9%
ZoneAlarm96.4%94.5%
Number of samples113055683054

Full testing methodology is here.

Posted on 13 March 2008 by Virus Bulletin

 Tags

AV-Test testing
twitter.png
fb.png
linkedin.png
hackernews.png
reddit.png

 

Latest posts:

Nominations opened for sixth Péter Szőr Award

Virus Bulletin is seeking nominations for the sixth annual Péter Szőr Award.

Haroon Meer and Adrian Sanabria to deliver VB2019 closing keynote

New additions to the VB2019 conference programme include a closing keynote address from Thinkst duo Haroon Meer and Adrian Sanabria and a talk on attacks against payment systems.

Free VB2019 tickets for students

Virus Bulletin is excited to announce that, thanks to generous sponsorship from Google Android, we are able to offer 20 free tickets to students who want to attend VB2019.

VB2018 paper: Lazarus Group: a mahjong game played with different sets of tiles

The Lazarus Group, generally linked to the North Korean government, is one of the most notorious threat groups seen in recent years. At VB2018 ESET researchers Peter Kálnai and Michal Poslušný presented a paper looking at the group's various…

Book your VB2019 ticket now for a chance to win a ticket for BSides London

Virus Bulletin is proud to sponsor this year's BSides London conference, which will take place next week, and we have a number of tickets to give away.

We have placed cookies on your device in order to improve the functionality of this site, as outlined in our cookies policy. However, you may delete and block all cookies from this site and your use of the site will be unaffected. By continuing to browse this site, you are agreeing to Virus Bulletin's use of data as outlined in our privacy policy.