AV-Test release latest results

Posted by   Virus Bulletin on   Sep 2, 2008

Major test of suite products completed

Independent testing body AV-Test.org has released the results of a major comparative of suite products, with many vendors' 2009 editions included in the results. The test covers a range of metrics, including detection rates over various types of malware including adware and spyware, false positive rates, scanning speed, proactive detection, and response times to outbreaks.

In terms of pure detection rates in on-demand scanning, a beta version of GDATA's AVK 2009 topped the charts for both 'malware' (measured against 1,164,662 samples) and 'ad- and spyware' (94,291 samples), with Avira's Premium Security Suite 2008 a close runner-up in the former category and F-Secure 2009 placing second in the latter. Secure Computing's Webwasher gateway product, based on the Avira engine with some in-house heuristics, came third in both categories.

Other areas analysed were scored on a five-point scale from very good to very poor. 'Proactive' protection included scanning of files discovered after the freezing of products, and executing unrecognised malware to test behavioural protection. Products rating 'good' or better in every category include Avira's premium suite (the popular free version has less complete spyware detection), AVK 2009, F-Secure's 2009 suite, Symantec's Norton I.S. 2009 (still in beta) and Sophos's Security Suite 2.5. All products taking part in the test managed to achieve a 'good' or better in at least one category.

The test also included keeping a record of the number of updates released over a four-week period. Of course, these numbers on their own cannot be used to measure the quality of the products involved, but were recorded out of interest. The most interesting data to emerge from this measurement was that the 2009 version of Norton topped the table with an impressive 6,202 incremental micro-updates, issued several times per hour, while Kaspersky came a distant second with a mere 696. Half of the 34 products tested had fewer than 100, including those from McAfee (21) and Trend Micro (30).

A summary of the major areas tested is printed below; hover over the product names to see full version information.

Productmalware on demandadware / spyware on demandfalse positivesscan speedproactive detectionresponse timesmalware on demandadware / spyware on demand
AntiVir (Avira)++++ (4)++++++99.8%99.0%
Avast! (Alwil)++++++oo99.3%98.3%
AVG+- (4)++oo95.8%87.0%
AVK 2008 (G Data) (1)++++o-+++99.2%99.1%
AVK 2009 (G Data) (2)++++++++++99.8%99.8%
BitDefender 2008+-+-+++97.7%87.8%
BitDefender 2009+-+o+++97.6%88.0%
CA-AV (VET)----++o---65.5%68.0%
ClamAV-o----++88.5%92.8%
Dr Web---oo+o84.9%89.6%
eScan++o-+++97.8%97.4%
Fortinet-GWo--o++++92.6%81.9%
F-Prot (Frisk)oo++oo94.8%92.6%
F-Secure 2008+++++o+++98.2%98.4%
F-Secure 2009++++++++++99.2%99.6%
Ikarus++++o+++99.5%98.6%
K7 Computingooo++-o92.1%94.0%
Kaspersky++++oo+++98.4%98.3%
McAfeeoo++o+-93.6%94.5%
Microsoft++++o--97.7%97.1%
Nod32 (Eset)oo+++++++94.4%94.7%
Norman+++o+o96.3%95.8%
Norton 2008 (Symantec)+o++++o97.8%94.6%
Norton 2009 (Symantec)++++++++++98.7%95.4%
Panda 2008-o++++o86.4%93.4%
Panda 2009o++++++91.8%95.6%
Rising----+ooo83.4%77.5%
Sophos+++++++97.5%95.0%
Trend Microo-++o+91.3%88.5%
TrustPort++++---++++99.5%98.4%
VBA32o-oo+o90.5%85.2%
VirusBuster--++oo89.0%85.8%
WebWasher-GW (3)++++o++++++99.7%99.2%
ZoneAlarm++oo+++97.8%97.7%
Indexmalware on demandadware / spyware on demandfalse positivesscan speedproactive detectionresponse timesmalware on demandadware / spyware on demand
++>98%>98%no FP< 2 h
+>95%>95%1-2 FP2 - 4 h
o>90%>90%3-4 FP4 - 6 h
->85%>85%5-6 FP6 - 8 h
--<85%<85%> 6 FP> 8 h

Notes
(1) AVK 2008 uses the Avast and Kaspersky scan engines
(2) AVK 2009 uses the Avast and BitDefender scan engines
(3) WebWasher uses the Avira engine and a self-developed heuristic engine
(4) the free (personal) edition does not include ad- and spyware detection, so the results would be --

Posted on 02 September 2008 by Virus Bulletin

twitter.png
fb.png
linkedin.png
googleplus.png
reddit.png

 

Latest posts:

Firefox 59 to make it a lot harder to use data URIs in phishing attacks

Firefox developer Mozilla has announced that, as of version 59 of the browser, many kinds of data URIs, which provide a way to create "domainless web content", will not be rendered in the browser, thus making this trick - used in various phishing…

Standalone product test: FireEye Endpoint

Virus Bulletin ran a standalone test on FireEye's Endpoint Security solution.

VB2017 video: Consequences of bad security in health care

Jelena Milosevic, a nurse with a passion for IT security, is uniquely placed to witness poor security practices in the health care sector, and to fully understand the consequences. Today, we publish the recording of a presentation given by Jelena at…

Vulnerabilities play only a tiny role in the security risks that come with mobile phones

Both bad news (all devices were pwnd) and good news (pwning is increasingly difficult) came from the most recent mobile Pwn2Own competition. But the practical security risks that come with using mobile phones have little to do with vulnerabilities.

VB2017 paper: The (testing) world turned upside down

At VB2017 in Madrid, industry veteran and ESET Senior Research Fellow David Harley presented a paper on the state of security software testing. Today we publish David's paper in both HTML and PDF format.