Five tips for submitting to Calls for Papers

Posted by   Martijn Grooten on   Aug 9, 2017

Two weeks ago, we opened the call for last-minute papers for VB2017. Like most CPFs, the number of submissions will far exceed the number of available slots. There is no golden rule for getting your submission accepted at our or any other conference, but here are five things that could help improve your chances.


All research is treated equally, but some research is more equal than others

Let's face it: if your research into a botnet that uses Windows XP machines to mine Bitcoin is up against a submission about an APT group that uses three zero-days to bridge air-gaps, you'll have a harder time convincing a selection committee of the value of your work.

Now, we can (and probably should) have a discussion about whether our focus as a community is the right one, but if your research lacks a 'coolness' factor you will have to try a little bit harder. So do explain why your research may be relevant for the bigger picture, or what makes it unique. We actually value good research into less 'cool' subjects, but be aware that you may have to work a bit harder to convince us.

If it sounds too good to be true, we will assume it is too good be true

Your presentation time will be limited (30 minutes, in the case of the VB conference), and this naturally limits how much you'll be able to put into your presentation. Keep this in mind when writing the abstract: if you want to cover a lot, make it clear you'll only be touching the surface, or that you'll go into in more detail on just one or two things.

Obfuscation is a useful tool, but not in your abstract!

Every year, there are a number of abstracts that solicit a simple comment from selection committee members: 'Huh?!?'.

The members of the selection committee will have to wade through dozens of abstracts. They don't have the time to do background research or to read your submission three times to understand what you really mean. Make sure your abstract is clearly written and can be understood by anyone with some years of security experience.

Don't have your marketing department write your abstract

We get it: your employer pays for the time you spend doing research, they pay for your travel expenses, and they miss you from the office for several days when you attend a conference. Of course they will want to see the exposure you get reflect well on them. That's fine: we, like most conferences, are happy for employers to do some marketing around your talk; we also are more than happy for you to use your logo on your slides.

But like most security conferences, the Virus Bulletin conference is not a marketing event. Unless it is particularly relevant to the talk (for example, Apple research into OS X malware), mentioning your company name in the abstract is likely to reduce your chances of being selected, so in case of doubt, don't do it.

It is okay not to be chosen

Finally, most CFPs are several times oversubscribed. Based on past experience, there is about a 20% chance of your VB2017 last-minute submission being accepted. Please don't hesitate to ask for feedback on why your abstract wasn't selected, but do keep in mind that there isn't always a clear reason, other than the fact that the number of available slots was limited.

Luckily there are many security conferences. Keep working on your research, keep writing about it on blogs and social media, and keep submitting to CFPs. Your time will come!





Latest posts:

VB2017 paper: The life story of an IPT - Inept Persistent Threat actor

At VB2017 in Madrid, Polish security researcher and journalist Adam Haertlé presented a paper about a very inept persistent threat. Today, we publish both the paper and the recording of Adam's presentation.

Five reasons to submit a VB2018 paper this weekend

The call for papers for VB2018 closes on 18 March, and while we've already received many great submissions, we still want more! Here are five reasons why you should submit a paper this weekend.

First partners of VB2018 announced

We are excited to announce the first six companies to partner with VB2018.

VB2018: looking for technical and non-technical talks

We like to pick good, solid technical talks for the VB conference programme, but good talks don't have to be technical and we welcome less technical submissions just as much.

Partner with VB2018 for extra visibility among industry peers

Partnering with the VB conference links your company to a successful and well-established event, demonstrates your commitment to moving the industry forward, allows you to meet potential clients, be visible to industry peers and build lasting…